The “What Would You Rather Do?” - After Dark Party Game
Pick Your Poison is a card game of unbelievable what would you rather do scenarios.
Three or more players compete to create the hardest scenario possible by combining two Poison Cards (300+ included).
Everyone anonymously “Picks their poison” – After the reveal, find out who was “right” and who is just as messed up as you thought.
Combine with the NSFW Edition for even more fun!
How to Play
1. Getting Started
All players should start with the following nine cards.
2. Select Card A
The Judge selects one of their cards and places it on the “Card A” Spot on the game mat.
3. Submit
Picking Players (everyone except the judge) submit one card from their hand to the Judge.
4. Select Card B
The Judge reads the cards out loud and chooses the one that’s the most comparable to “Card A,” The player that submitted the chosen card receives one point.
5. Clarify
The Picking players ask the Judge clarifying questions about the two Poison cards (card A and card B). The Judge can elaborate on each scenario however they like.
6. Pick
Picking players anony
mously select the Poison card that they would rather do by playing their corresponding Pick card face down.
7. Reveal
The Picking players reveal their choices and points are tallied by the Judge.
